Architecture Question: GWT or Vaadin to create Desktop Application?

gwt desktop-application wicket ria vaadin
Akku picture Akku · Mar 10, 2011 · Viewed 8.7k times · Source

We're planning on creating a feedreader as a windows desktop- and iPad application. As we want to be able to show Websites AND to run (our own) JavaScript in this application, we thought about delivering the application as HTML/CSS/JavaScript, just wrapped by some .NET control or a Cocoa Touch webbrowser component. So the task at hand is to find out which framework to use to create the HTML/CSS/JS files to embed in the application.

For the development of the HTML/CSS/JavaScript we would be happy to use Vaadin, GWT, or some other framework, as we're a lot better with Java than with JS. We favor Vaadin after a short brainstorming, as the UI components are very nice, but I fear that most of the heavy lifting will be on the server and not in the client (and that wouldn't be too nice). We would also like GWT, but the Java-to-JS compiling takes a lot of time and an extra step, and slowed down development time in the past when using it.

The question is: which development framework would you choose (given you wanted to implement this project and you mostly did Java so far) and why? If there are better framework options (List of Rich Client Frameworks), please let me know.

Edit: The application will need to talk to our server from time to time (sync what has been read for example), but mainly should get the xml feeds itself. Therefore I hope that most of the generated code can be embedded in the application and there doesn't need to be heavy activity with our server.

Edit2: We (realistically even if you doubt) expect at least 10000 users.

Answer

eeq picture eeq · Mar 11, 2011

Based on my experience with Vaadin, I'd go for that, but your requirements are somewhat favoring pure-GWT instead.

  • Vaadin needs the server and server connection. If building mostly offline desktop application, this can be solved with an embedded Jetty for example. (synchronize with an online service only when needed), but for iPad you would need to connect online right away to start the Vaadin application.
  • GWT runs completely at the client-side and you can build a JavaScript browser application that only connects when needed.

Because Vaadin is much quicker to develop, you could build a small Vaadin version first and see if that is actually problem on the iPad.

On the other hand, if you can assume going online right away, you can skip the local server installation altogether. Just run the application online and implement the desktop version using operating systems default browser control (i.e. the .NET control you suggested). Then Vaadin is easier.

Related questions

How do I pass a class as a parameter in Java?

Is there any way to pass class as a parameter in Java and fire some methods from that class? void main() { callClass(that.class) } void callClass(???? classObject) { classObject.somefunction // or new classObject() //something like that ? } I am using Google Web …

Read More
java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: org/apache/http/client/HttpClient

I am trying to make a get request from the GWT servlet to get JSON response from a web service. Following is the code in my servlet : public String getQueData() throws IllegalArgumentException { String message = null; try { HttpClient httpclient = new DefaultHttpClient(); …

Read More
ClassNotFoundException: org.slf4j.LoggerFactory

I am trying to run GWT RequestFactory and facing this error: ClassNotFoundException: org.slf4j.LoggerFactory I have tried to download slf4j-api-1.3.1.jar but it didnt resolve the issue Any idea exactly which jar I need to download ?

Read More