Reasons for not working on the master branch in Git

git version-control branch dvcs
Mark Williams picture Mark Williams · Apr 19, 2011 · Viewed 14.5k times · Source

So, I'm fairly new to git and I've after a bit of reading around over the last couple of weeks I've read a few people saying that the master branch shouldn't be changed but rather branched from and then merged to.

I'm happy enough to work with branches but was wondering for the reasons behind not working on the master branch?

Answer

Karl Bielefeldt picture Karl Bielefeldt · Apr 19, 2011

Other people have made very good cases for not making changes directly in master, and I agree with them. However, always advocating workflows like this sometimes leads people new to git to believe it is needlessly complex, so I wanted to provide a counterpoint.

If you have a one-person or very small team and your development is highly linear, i.e. you rarely work on more than one thing at a time and each feature is usually completed before starting the next, there really is little to no benefit to not work directly out of master. It is very easy to go back and add a branch at any point should the need arise. I highly recommend being aware of the feature branch workflow, but if you feel in your case it's just adding extra steps without buying you anything, I promise I won't tell the git police.

Related questions

Moving master head to a branch

I have several feature branches and a master branch. Feature2 is done. Normally I would rebase (working with a remote SVN repo and would like to keep the history, so no regular merge) and ff-merge. But since master hasnt changed …

Read More
How can I delete all Git branches which have been merged?

I have many Git branches. How do I delete branches which have already been merged? Is there an easy way to delete them all instead of deleting them one by one?

Read More
How can I get a list of Git branches, ordered by most recent commit?

I want to get a list of all the branches in a Git repository with the "freshest" branches at the top, where the "freshest" branch is the one that's been committed to most recently (and is, therefore, more likely to …

Read More