How do I push amended commit to the remote Git repository?

git git-commit amend
Spoike picture Spoike · Oct 31, 2008 · Viewed 411.4k times · Source

When I've worked a bit with my source code, I did my usual thing commit and then I pushed to a remote repository. But then I noticed I forgot to organize my imports in the source code. So I do the amend command to replace the previous commit:

> git commit --amend

Unfortunately the commit can't be pushed back to the repository. It is rejected like this:

> git push origin
To //my.remote.repo.com/stuff.git/
 ! [rejected]        master -> master (non-fast forward)
error: failed to push some refs to '//my.remote.repo.com/stuff.git/'

What should I do? (I can access the remote repository.)

Answer

gitster picture gitster · Jan 11, 2009

I actually once pushed with --force and .git repository and got scolded by Linus BIG TIME. In general this will create a lot of problems for other people. A simple answer is "Don't do it".

I see others gave the recipe for doing so anyway, so I won't repeat them here. But here is a tip to recover from the situation after you have pushed out the amended commit with --force (or +master).

  1. Use git reflog to find the old commit that you amended (call it old, and we'll call the new commit you created by amending new).
  2. Create a merge between old and new, recording the tree of new, like git checkout new && git merge -s ours old.
  3. Merge that to your master with git merge master
  4. Update your master with the result with git push . HEAD:master
  5. Push the result out.

Then people who were unfortunate enough to have based their work on the commit you obliterated by amending and forcing a push will see the resulting merge will see that you favor new over old. Their later merges will not see the conflicts between old and new that resulted from your amending, so they do not have to suffer.

Related questions

How to modify existing, unpushed commit messages?

I wrote the wrong thing in a commit message. How can I change the message? The commit has not been pushed yet.

Read More
How to amend a commit without changing commit message (reusing the previous one)?

Is there a way to amend a commit without vi (or your $EDITOR) popping up with the option to modify your commit message, but simply reusing the previous message?

Read More
Edit the root commit in Git?

There's ways to change the message from later commits: git commit --amend # for the most recent commit git rebase --interactive master~2 # but requires *parent* How can you change the commit message of the very first commit (which has no parent)?

Read More