Advantages of stateless programming?

functional-programming state immutability
Sasha Chedygov picture Sasha Chedygov · May 10, 2009 · Viewed 58.7k times · Source

I've recently been learning about functional programming (specifically Haskell, but I've gone through tutorials on Lisp and Erlang as well). While I found the concepts very enlightening, I still don't see the practical side of the "no side effects" concept. What are the practical advantages of it? I'm trying to think in the functional mindset, but there are some situations that just seem overly complex without the ability to save state in an easy way (I don't consider Haskell's monads 'easy').

Is it worth continuing to learn Haskell (or another purely functional language) in-depth? Is functional or stateless programming actually more productive than procedural? Is it likely that I will continue to use Haskell or another functional language later, or should I learn it only for the understanding?

I care less about performance than productivity. So I'm mainly asking if I will be more productive in a functional language than a procedural/object-oriented/whatever.

Answer

Juliet picture Juliet · May 10, 2009

Read Functional Programming in a Nutshell.

There are lots of advantages to stateless programming, not least of which is dramatically multithreaded and concurrent code. To put it bluntly, mutable state is enemy of multithreaded code. If values are immutable by default, programmers don't need to worry about one thread mutating the value of shared state between two threads, so it eliminates a whole class of multithreading bugs related to race conditions. Since there are no race conditions, there's no reason to use locks either, so immutability eliminates another whole class of bugs related to deadlocks as well.

That's the big reason why functional programming matters, and probably the best one for jumping on the functional programming train. There are also lots of other benefits, including simplified debugging (i.e. functions are pure and do not mutate state in other parts of an application), more terse and expressive code, less boilerplate code compared to languages which are heavily dependent on design patterns, and the compiler can more aggressively optimize your code.

Related questions

How can you do anything useful without mutable state?

I've been reading a lot of stuff about functional programming lately, and I can understand most of it, but the one thing I just can't wrap my head around is stateless coding. It seems to me that simplifying programming by …

Read More
map function for objects (instead of arrays)

I have an object: myObject = { 'a': 1, 'b': 2, 'c': 3 } I am looking for a native method, similar to Array.prototype.map that would be used as follows: newObject = myObject.map(function (value, label) { return value * value; }); // newObject is now { 'a': 1, 'b': 4, …

Read More
Does JavaScript have a method like "range()" to generate a range within the supplied bounds?

In PHP, you can do... range(1, 3); // Array(1, 2, 3) range("A", "C"); // Array("A", "B", "C") That is, there is a function that lets you get a range of numbers or characters by passing the upper and lower bounds. Is there anything …

Read More