Bizzare "attempt to call a table value" in Lua

for-loop lua runtime-error next garrys-mod
Schilcote picture Schilcote · Apr 28, 2014 · Viewed 27.2k times · Source

The following code snippet:

for weight, item in itemlist do
    weight_total=weight_total+weight
end

is causing the error "attempt to call table value" on the first line in that snippet. Why?

Itemlist is a table of tables of weights and strings, like such:

local itemlist = {
                        {4,"weapon_pistol"},
                        {2,"weapon_357"},
                        ...

Nothing is being called as far as I can tell; why is this error coming up?

Answer

Deduplicator picture Deduplicator · Apr 28, 2014

The generic for expects 3 arguments: a callable value, some value which is repeatedly passed to it, and the key where the iteration shall start.
Stock lua does not call pairs on the first value passed to for if that's not callable, though some derivatives do.

Thus, you must use ipairs(itemlist), pairs(itemlist), next, itemlist or whatever you want (the last two have identical behavior, and are what most derivatives do).

As an example, an iterator unpacking the value sequence:

function awesome_next(t, k)
    k, t = next(t, k)
    if not t then return end
    return k, table.unpack(t)
end

for k, a, b, c, d in awesome_next, t do
end

Related questions

For Loop on Lua

My assignment is how to do a for loop. I have figured it out in terms of numbers but cannot figure it out in terms of names. I would like to create a for loop that runs down a list …

Read More
What is the difference of pairs() vs. ipairs() in Lua?

In a for loop, what is the difference between looping with pairs() and ipairs()? This page uses both: Lua Docs With ipairs(): a = {"one", "two", "three"} for i, v in ipairs(a) do print(i, v) end Result: 1 one 2 two 3 …

Read More
Loop through an array in JavaScript

In Java you can use a for loop to traverse objects in an array as follows: String[] myStringArray = {"Hello", "World"}; for (String s : myStringArray) { // Do something } Can you do the same in JavaScript?

Read More