In Emacs, what does this error mean? "Warning: cl package required at runtime"

emacs lisp common-lisp
Cheeso picture Cheeso · Feb 16, 2011 · Viewed 10.5k times · Source

I am byte-compiling a module. It gives me this warning:

 Warning: cl package required at runtime

Why is this a warning? I am well aware that I am using the cl package. In fact there is a (require 'cl) statement in the module.

Is there something wrong with using the cl stuff?

If so, is there a list of published workarounds? The main things I use are mapcan and delete-duplicates.

Answer

Oleg Pavliv picture Oleg Pavliv · Feb 16, 2011

The reason of this warning is a GNU policy which does not want a package cl to be used in Elisp. But it would be foolish as well to prohibit it completely. So they decided to show a warning.

You can find more information here

Related questions

Best Common Lisp IDE

I've used Slime within Emacs as my primary development environment for Common Lisp (or Aquamacs on OS X), but are there other compelling choices out there? I've heard about Lispworks, but is that [or something else] worth looking at? Or …

Read More
What is the closest thing to Slime for Scheme?

I do most of my development in Common Lisp, but there are some moments when I want to switch to Scheme (while reading Lisp in Small Pieces, when I want to play with continuations, or when I want to do …

Read More
In Emacs Lisp, how do I check if a variable is defined?

In Emacs Lisp, how do I check if a variable is defined?

Read More