Advantages and disadvantages of GUID / UUID database keys
I've worked on a number of database systems in the past where moving entries between databases would have been made a lot easier if all the database keys had been GUID / UUID values. I've considered going down this path a few times, but there's always a bit of uncertainty, especially around performance and un-read-out-over-the-phone-able URLs.
Has anyone worked extensively with GUIDs in a database? What advantages would I get by going that way, and what are the likely pitfalls?
Answer
Advantages:
- Can generate them offline.
- Makes replication trivial (as opposed to int's, which makes it REALLY hard)
- ORM's usually like them
- Unique across applications. So We can use the PK's from our CMS (guid) in our app (also guid) and know we are NEVER going to get a clash.
Disadvantages:
- Larger space use, but space is cheap(er)
- Can't order by ID to get the insert order.
- Can look ugly in a URL, but really, WTF are you doing putting a REAL DB key in a URL!? (This point disputed in comments below)
- Harder to do manual debugging, but not that hard.
Personally, I use them for most PK's in any system of a decent size, but I got "trained" on a system which was replicated all over the place, so we HAD to have them. YMMV.
I think the duplicate data thing is rubbish - you can get duplicate data however you do it. Surrogate keys are usually frowned upon where ever I've been working. We DO use the WordPress-like system though:
- unique ID for the row (GUID/whatever). Never visible to the user.
- public ID is generated ONCE from some field (e.g. the title - make it the-title-of-the-article)
UPDATE: So this one gets +1'ed a lot, and I thought I should point out a big downside of GUID PK's: Clustered Indexes.
If you have a lot of records, and a clustered index on a GUID, your insert performance will SUCK, as you get inserts in random places in the list of items (thats the point), not at the end (which is quick)
So if you need insert performance, maybe use a auto-inc INT, and generate a GUID if you want to share it with someone else (ie, show it to a user in a URL)