What does "request for member '*******' in something not a structure or union" mean?

c struct unions
Pieter picture Pieter · Feb 2, 2010 · Viewed 227.2k times · Source

Is there an easy explanation for what this error means?

request for member '*******' in something not a structure or union

I've encountered it several times in the time that I've been learning C, but I haven't got a clue as to what it means.

Answer

unwind picture unwind · Feb 2, 2010

It also happens if you're trying to access an instance when you have a pointer, and vice versa:

struct foo
{
  int x, y, z;
};

struct foo a, *b = &a;

b.x = 12;  /* This will generate the error, should be b->x or (*b).x */

As pointed out in a comment, this can be made excruciating if someone goes and typedefs a pointer, i.e. includes the * in a typedef, like so:

typedef struct foo* Foo;

Because then you get code that looks like it's dealing with instances, when in fact it's dealing with pointers:

Foo a_foo = get_a_brand_new_foo();
a_foo->field = FANTASTIC_VALUE;

Note how the above looks as if it should be written a_foo.field, but that would fail since Foo is a pointer to struct. I strongly recommend against typedef:ed pointers in C. Pointers are important, don't hide your asterisks. Let them shine.

Related questions

Difference between a Structure and a Union

Is there any good example to give the difference between a struct and a union? Basically I know that struct uses all the memory of its member and union uses the largest members memory space. Is there any other OS …

Read More
How to compile C code with anonymous structs / unions?

I can do this in c++/g++: struct vec3 { union { struct { float x, y, z; }; float xyz[3]; }; }; Then, vec3 v; assert(&v.xyz[0] == &v.x); assert(&v.xyz[1] == &v.y); assert(&v.xyz[2] == &v.…

Read More
Anonymous union within struct not in c99?

here is very simplified code of problem I have: enum node_type { t_int, t_double }; struct int_node { int value; }; struct double_node { double value; }; struct node { enum node_type type; union { struct int_node int_n; struct double_…

Read More