Why should I use, or not use, MSG_CONFIRM?

c sockets arp
qdii picture qdii · May 16, 2013 · Viewed 10.5k times · Source

I am acquainting with BSD sockets, and flicking through the man page of sendto, I bumped into MSG_CONFIRM flag, which is quite mysterious to me at the moment.

The description says:

Tell the link layer that forward progress happened: you got a successful reply from the other side. If the link layer doesn't get this it will regularly reprobe the neighbor (e.g., via a unicast ARP). Only valid on SOCK_DGRAM and SOCK_RAW sockets and currently implemented only for IPv4 and IPv6.

After a quick look at the man page of arp, I understand that flagging something MSG_CONFIRM prevents the ARP mapping MAC address ↔ IP address of the remote machine from being considered stale.

Now I am puzzled because I can’t see any reason why I should not put it, and therefore, why didn’t they enforce that directly in the library. Why is the application layer expected to deal with anything that happens down there at the link layer.

So did I miss anything? when should I set it, or not set it?

Answer

caf picture caf · Feb 8, 2017

You should only set the flag if the datagram you're sending is a direct response to a datagram you just received from the same peer.

If you're sending an initial request, or sending a datagram in response to some other event (like user input, or a timeout) then you should not set the MSG_CONFIRM flag.

Related questions

What can be the reasons of connection refused errors?

I'm trying to write a server program in C, using another client, I get this error when I try to connect through port 2080 for example. connection refused What can be the reasons of this error?

Read More
close vs shutdown socket?

In C, I understood that if we close a socket, it means the socket will be destroyed and can be re-used later. How about shutdown? The description said it closes half of a duplex connection to that socket. But will …

Read More
How to set socket timeout in C when making multiple connections?

I'm writing a simple program that makes multiple connections to different servers for status check. All these connections are constructed on-demand; up to 10 connections can be created simultaneously. I don't like the idea of one-thread-per-socket, so I made all these …

Read More