Why use asprintf() instead of sprintf()?

Question

I'm having a hard time understanding why you would need asprintf. Here in the manual it says

The functions asprintf() and vasprintf() are analogs of sprintf(3) and vsprintf(3), except that they allocate a string large enough to hold the output including the terminating null byte, and return a pointer to it via the first argument. This pointer should be passed to free(3) to release the allocated storage when it is no longer needed.

So here is the example that I'm trying to understand:

asprintf(&buffer, "/bin/echo %s is cool", getenv("USER"));

What's the difference if the buffer allocates a string large enough vs saying char* = (string)

Answer 1

If you use sprintf() or vsprintf(), you need to allocate a buffer first, and you need to be sure that the buffer is large enough to contain what sprintf writes. Otherwise sprintf() will happily overwrite whatever memory lies beyond the end of the buffer.

char* x = malloc(5 * sizeof(char));
// writes "123456" +null but overruns the buffer
sprintf(x,"%s%s%s", "12", "34", "56");

... writes the '6' and the terminating null beyond the end of the space allocated to x, either corrupting some other variable, or causing a segmentation fault.

If you're lucky, it will trample on memory in-between allocated blocks, and will do no harm -- this time. This leads to intermittent bugs -- the hardest kind to diagnose. It's good to use a tool like ElectricFence that causes overruns to fail-fast.

A non-malicious user who provides an overlong input, could cause the program to behave in unexpected ways. A malicious user could exploit this as a way to get their own executable code into the system.

One guard against this is to use snprintf(), which truncates the string to the maximum length you supply.

char *x = malloc(5 * sizeof(char));
int size = snprintf(x, 5, "%s%s%s", "12", "34", "56"); // writes "1234" + null

The return value size is the length that would have been written if space was available -- not including the terminating null.

In this case, if size is greater than or equal to 5 then you know that truncation occurred - and if you didn't want truncation, you could allocate a new string and try snprintf() again.

char *x = malloc(BUF_LEN * sizeof(char));
int size = snprintf(x, 5, "%s%s%s", "12", "34", "56");
if (size >= BUF_LEN) {
    realloc(&x,(size + 1) * sizeof(char));
    snprintf(x, size + 1 , "%s%s%s", "12", "34", "56");
}

(That's a pretty naive algorithm, but it illustrates the point. There may yet be bugs in it, which further illustrates the point -- this stuff is easy to screw up.)

asprintf() does this in one step for you - calculates the length of the string, allocates that amount of memory, and writes the string into it.

char *x;
int size = asprintf(&x, "%s%s%s", "12", "34", "56");

In all cases, once you've finished with x you need to release it, or you leak memory:

free(x);

asprintf() is an implicit malloc(), so you have to check it worked, just as you would with malloc() or any other system call.

if (size == -1 ) {
   /* deal with error in some way */
}

Note that asprintf() is part of the GNU and BSD extensions to libc - you can't be sure it will be available in every C environment. sprintf() and snprintf() are part of the POSIX and C99 standards.