Template specialization for an empty parameter pack

Question

I have a variadic template function which calls itself to determine the largest number in a list (constituted by the templatized arguments). I am trying to make a specialization for when the parameter pack is empty so I can just return the number at the front of the list, but I don't know how to do that. I am just becoming familiar with variadic templates and template specialization, but this is what I have so far:

#include <string>
#include <iostream>

using namespace std;

template <int N, int... N2>
int tmax() {
    return N > tmax<N2...>() ? N : tmax<N2...>();
}

template <int N>
int tmax() {
    return N;
}

int main() {
    cout << tmax<32, 43, 54, 12, 23, 34>();
}

However, this produces the following error:

test.cpp: In function ‘int tmax() [with int N = 34, int ...N2 = {}]’:
test.cpp:9:45:   instantiated from ‘int tmax() [with int N = 23, int ...N2 = {34}]’
test.cpp:9:45:   instantiated from ‘int tmax() [with int N = 12, int ...N2 = {23, 34}]’
test.cpp:9:45:   instantiated from ‘int tmax() [with int N = 54, int ...N2 = {12, 23, 34}]’
test.cpp:9:45:   instantiated from ‘int tmax() [with int N = 43, int ...N2 = {54, 12, 23, 34}]’
test.cpp:9:45:   instantiated from ‘int tmax() [with int N = 32, int ...N2 = {43, 54, 12, 23, 34}]’
test.cpp:18:39:   instantiated from here
test.cpp:9:45: error: no matching function for call to ‘tmax()’
test.cpp:9:45: error: no matching function for call to ‘tmax()’

I have also tried this, just to see if it would work (although it introduces the number 0 to the list randomly so that it can't ever return a number less than 0):

template <int N, int... N2>
int tmax() {
    return N > tmax<N2...>() ? N : tmax<N2...>();
}

template <>
int tmax<>() {
    return 0;
}

However, in addition to the errors mentioned above, I get this error:

error: template-id ‘tmax<>’ for ‘int tmax()’ does not match any template declaration

So what should I do to get this working?

I am using g++ 4.5.2 with the -std=c++0x flag.

Answer 1

I see two mistakes using clang.

1. Put the overload taking a single int first.

2. Make things unambiguous for lists of length 1. Recall that variadic lists can have zero size and when they do, it seems to me you have an ambiguity.

This compiles and runs correctly for me:

#include <iostream>

using namespace std;

template <int N>
int tmax() {
    return N;
}

template <int N, int N1, int... N2>
int tmax() {
    return N > tmax<N1, N2...>() ? N : tmax<N1, N2...>();
}

int main() {
    cout << tmax<32, 43, 54, 12, 23, 34>();
}

54