Why STL containers are preferred over MFC containers?

c++ mfc stl containers
Naveen picture Naveen · Aug 28, 2009 · Viewed 7.9k times · Source

Previously, I used to use MFC collection classes such CArray and CMap. After a while I switched to STL containers and have been using them for a while. Although I find STL much better, I am unable to pin point the exact reasons for it. Some of the reasoning such as :

  1. It requires MFC: does not hold because other parts of my program uses MFC
  2. It is platform dependent: does not hold because I run my application only on windows.(No need for portability)
  3. It is defined in the C++ standard: OK, but MFC containers still work

The only reason I could come up is that I can use algorithms on the containers. Is there any other reason that I am missing here - what makes STL containers better than MFC containers?

Answer

Michael Burr picture Michael Burr · Aug 28, 2009

Ronald Laeremans, VC++ Product Unit Manager, even said to use STL in June 2006:

And frankly the team will give you the same answer. The MFC collection classes are only there for backwards compatibility. C++ has a standard for collection classes and that is the Standards C++ Library. There is no technical drawback for using any of the standard library in an MFC application.

We do not plan on making significant changes in this area.

Ronald Laeremans
Acting Product Unit Manager
Visual C++ Team

However, at one point where I was working on some code that ran during the installation phase of Windows, I was not permitted to use STL containers, but was told to use ATL containers instead (actually CString in particular, which I guess isn't really a container). The explanation was that the STL containers had dependecies on runtime bits that might not actually be available at the time the code had to execute, while those problems didn't exist for the ATL collections. This is a rather special scenario that shouldn't affect 99% of the code out there.

Related questions

Run MFC program on Linux

I have a rather large MFC based program. I have been tasked to get it running on Linux. I have explained that this will require a re-write of the program either into straight C++ with STL (more work), or into …

Read More
Private and Protected Members : C++

Can someone enlighten me as to the difference between private and protected members in classes? I understand from best practice conventions that variables and functions which are not called outside the class should be made private - but looking at …

Read More
How do you convert CString and std::string std::wstring to each other?

CString is quite handy, while std::string is more compatible with STL container. I am using hash_map. However, hash_map does not support CStrings as keys, so I want to convert the CString into a std::string. Writing a …

Read More