What causes memory fragmentation in .NET

c# .net memory-management memory-leaks fragmentation
Matt picture Matt · Mar 9, 2011 · Viewed 16.3k times · Source

I am using Red Gates ANTS memory profiler to debug a memory leak. It keeps warning me that:

Memory Fragmentation may be causing .NET to reserver too much free memory.

or

Memory Fragmentation is affecting the size of the largest object that can be allocated

Because I have OCD, this problem must be resolved.

What are some standard coding practices that help avoid memory fragmentation. Can you defragment it through some .NET methods? Would it even help?

Answer

John Leidegren picture John Leidegren · Mar 9, 2011

You know, I somewhat doubt the memory profiler here. The memory management system in .NET actually tries to defragment the heap for you by moving around memory (that's why you need to pin memory for it to be shared with an external DLL).

Large memory allocations taken over longer periods of time is prone to more fragmentation. While small ephemeral (short) memory requests are unlikely to cause fragmentation in .NET.

Here's also something worth thinking about. With the current GC of .NET, memory allocated close in time, is typically spaced close together in space. Which is the opposite of fragmentation. i.e. You should allocate memory the way you intend to access it.

Is it a managed code only or does it contains stuff like P/Invoke, unmanaged memory (Marshal.AllocHGlobal) or stuff like GCHandle.Alloc(obj, GCHandleType.Pinned)?

Related questions

Implementing IDisposable correctly

In my classes I implement IDisposable as follows: public class User : IDisposable { public int id { get; protected set; } public string name { get; protected set; } public string pass { get; protected set; } public User(int UserID) { id = UserID; } public User(string Username, …

Read More
What strategies and tools are useful for finding memory leaks in .NET?

I wrote C++ for 10 years. I encountered memory problems, but they could be fixed with a reasonable amount of effort. For the last couple of years I've been writing C#. I find I still get lots of memory problems. They're …

Read More
Large Object Heap Fragmentation

The C#/.NET application I am working on is suffering from a slow memory leak. I have used CDB with SOS to try to determine what is happening but the data does not seem to make any sense so I …

Read More