How to Setup a readonly property with Moq?

c# moq readonly-attribute
M.Tach picture M.Tach · Aug 15, 2016 · Viewed 12.5k times · Source

I am trying to unit test using Moq. Here is the example code:

public class ConcreteClass
{
    private readonly FirstPropery firstProperty;
    private readonly SecondProperty secondProperty;

    public ConcreteClass(firstProperty, secondProperty)
    {
        this.firstProperty = firstProperty;
        this.secondProperty = secondProperty;
    }
}

[TestMethod]
    var concreteClassMock = new Mock<ConcreteClass>() { CallBase = true };

In my test method, I want to set firstProperty to reference a real object FirstProperty object (created by a factory), and later use it to test another object's behavior. Is there any way to achieve that?

Answer

poke picture poke · Aug 15, 2016

Usually, you wouldn’t mock private members since you are only mocking the public interface of something. A mock is thus completely independent of implementation details.

That being said, you can pass constructor arguments to the Mock constructor that will then be passed on to the target’s constructor:

new Mock<ConcreteClass>(firstProperty, secondProperty) {CallBase = true};

However, if your goal is to actually test the ConcreteClass, you should not create a mock of it. You should test the actual object. So mock its dependencies and pass those if necessary, but keep the object you want to test actually real. Otherwise, you might introduce and test behavior that comes from the mock instead of the object you are testing:

var firstMock = new Mock<FirstProperty>();
var secondMock = new Mock<FirstProperty>();

var obj = new ConcreteClass(firstMock.Object, secondMock.Object);

obj.DoSomething();
// assert stuff

Related questions

Verify a method call using Moq

I am fairly new to unit testing in C# and learning to use Moq. Below is the class that I am trying to test. class MyClass { SomeClass someClass; public MyClass(SomeClass someClass) { this.someClass = someClass; } public void MyMethod(string method) { …

Read More
Why am I getting an Exception with the message "Invalid setup on a non-virtual (overridable in VB) member..."?

I have a unit test where I have to mock a non-virtual method that returns a bool type public class XmlCupboardAccess { public bool IsDataEntityInXmlCupboard(string dataId, out string nameInCupboard, out string refTypeInCupboard, string nameTemplate = null) { return IsDataEntityInXmlCupboard(_theDb, dataId, out …

Read More
How can I tell Moq to return a Task?

I've got an interface which declares Task DoSomethingAsync(); I'm using MoqFramework for my tests: [TestMethod()] public async Task MyAsyncTest() { Mock<ISomeInterface> mock = new Mock<ISomeInterface>(); mock.Setup(arg => arg.DoSomethingAsync()).Callback(() => { <my code …

Read More