Why is an out parameter not allowed within an anonymous method?

c# anonymous-methods out-parameters ref-parameters
Chris Ballance picture Chris Ballance · Oct 28, 2009 · Viewed 7.9k times · Source

This is not a dupe of Calling a method with ref or out parameters from an anonymous method

I am wondering why out parameters are not allowed within anonymous methods. Not allowing ref parameters makes a bit more sense to me, but the out parameters, not as much.

what are your thoughts on this

Answer

JaredPar picture JaredPar · Oct 28, 2009

In some ways this is a dupe. Out parameters are ref parameters. There is simply an extra attribute on the value that is used by the C# language. The reason for disallowing them is the exact same as ref parameters.

The problem here originates with the effect of using a value declared outside the anonymous method within the anonymous method. Doing so will capture the value within the lambda and out of necessity arbitrarily extend its lifetime beyond that of the current function. This is not compatible with out parameters which have a fixed lifetime.

Imagine for instance that the out parameter referred to a local variable on the stack. The lambda can execute at any arbitrary point in the future and hence could execute when that stack frame was no longer valid. What would the out parameter mean then?

Related questions

Anonymous method in Invoke call

Having a bit of trouble with the syntax where we want to call a delegate anonymously within a Control.Invoke. We have tried a number of different approaches, all to no avail. For example: myControl.Invoke(delegate() { MyMethod(this, new …

Read More
Is there a reason for C#'s reuse of the variable in a foreach?

When using lambda expressions or anonymous methods in C#, we have to be wary of the access to modified closure pitfall. For example: foreach (var s in strings) { query = query.Where(i => i.Prop == s); // access to modified closure ... } …

Read More
Unsubscribe anonymous method in C#

Is it possible to unsubscribe an anonymous method from an event? If I subscribe to an event like this: void MyMethod() { Console.WriteLine("I did it!"); } MyEvent += MyMethod; I can un-subscribe like this: MyEvent -= MyMethod; But if I subscribe …

Read More