Do C# Timers elapse on a separate thread?

c# multithreading timer
user113164 picture user113164 · Sep 17, 2009 · Viewed 112.3k times · Source

Does a System.Timers.Timer elapse on a separate thread than the thread that created it?

Lets say I have a class with a timer that fires every 5 seconds. When the timer fires, in the elapsed method, some object is modified. Lets say it takes a long time to modify this object, like 10 seconds. Is it possible that I will run into thread collisions in this scenario?

Answer

Brian Gideon picture Brian Gideon · Sep 17, 2009

It depends. The System.Timers.Timer has two modes of operation.

If SynchronizingObject is set to an ISynchronizeInvoke instance then the Elapsed event will execute on the thread hosting the synchronizing object. Usually these ISynchronizeInvoke instances are none other than plain old Control and Form instances that we are all familiar with. So in that case the Elapsed event is invoked on the UI thread and it behaves similar to the System.Windows.Forms.Timer. Otherwise, it really depends on the specific ISynchronizeInvoke instance that was used.

If SynchronizingObject is null then the Elapsed event is invoked on a ThreadPool thread and it behaves similar to the System.Threading.Timer. In fact, it actually uses a System.Threading.Timer behind the scenes and does the marshaling operation after it receives the timer callback if needed.

Related questions

Reliably stop System.Threading.Timer?

Well I've searched a lot for a solution to this. I'm looking for a clean and simple way to prevent the callback method of a System.Threading.Timer from being invoked after I've stopped it. I can't seem to find …

Read More
Proper way to implement a never ending task. (Timers vs Task)

So, my app needs to perform an action almost continuously (with a pause of 10 seconds or so between each run) for as long as the app is running or a cancellation is requested. The work it needs to do has …

Read More
Compare using Thread.Sleep and Timer for delayed execution

I have a method which should be delayed running for a specified amount of time. Should I use Thread thread = new Thread(() => { Thread.Sleep(millisecond); action(); }); thread.IsBackground = true; thread.Start(); Or Timer timer = new Timer(o => action(), …

Read More