Back in my C/C++ days, coding an "infinite loop" as
while (true)
felt more natural and seemed more obvious to me as opposed to
for (;;)
An encounter with PC-lint in the late 1980's and subsequent best practices discussions broke me of this habit. I have since coded the loops using the for
control statement. Today, for the first time in a long while, and perhaps my first need for an infinite loop as a C# developer, I am facing the same situation. Is one of them correct and the other not?
The C# compiler will transform both
for(;;)
{
// ...
}
and
while (true)
{
// ...
}
into
{
:label
// ...
goto label;
}
The CIL for both is the same. Most people find while(true)
to be easier to read and understand. for(;;)
is rather cryptic.
I messed a little more with .NET Reflector, and I compiled both loops with the "Optimize Code" on in Visual Studio.
Both loops compile into (with .NET Reflector):
Label_0000:
goto Label_0000;