Which Graphics Framework for Windows 8? MonoGame? OpenGL and Xaml/DirectX Mixing?

c# xaml windows-8 microsoft-metro winrt-xaml
lunatix picture lunatix · Sep 28, 2012 · Viewed 6.9k times · Source

I would like to develop a game for windows 8, but since Xna isn't supported, i don't really know, if it is good to use something like MonoGame - because i think, it doesn't make any sense to use MonoDevelop with OpenGL while the UI Frontend runs with DirectX. But my searches and on "apptivate.ms", they still force the developers to use MonoDevelop - but why would a corporation like Microsoft even do this?

And i don't like to build my game in C++ with DirectX, because in my case, it's not a big game, and my favorite language (also, my language at work) is C#..

Btw., it would not be a big deal for me to write this game with OpenGL or C++, because I've got a lot of experience in these two for the past four years, but in this case, i like to have a "fast" and "save" solution like C# and a Graphics Framework.

So... maybe someone has the answer to these qustions:

  • Should i use MonoGame with Xaml / C# and don't worry about the mix of DirectX and OpenGL?
  • Or is there even another DirectX/Game Framework which i can use?
  • Or maybe, i'm totally wrong, and Xaml doesn't need DirectX? Or i can force MonoGame to use DirectX?
  • Or, another point - would something like "System.Drawing" fast enough for a spaceshooter with some nice shading effects (I think, for my case, i need shading and something like bloom, blurring etc.)? Maybe, Microsoft added a new 2D drawing library? (But i think its still gdi+ )

Answer

xoofx picture xoofx · Sep 29, 2012

Your question is ambiguous if you are referring to Windows 8 Metro (aka Modern) or Windows 8 Desktop, but I assume it's the Metro version.

If you want to develop a game in C# for Win8 Metro without using a commercial solution, you can use:

  • SharpDX which is a low level DirectX API for .NET or the up-coming SharpDX.Toolkit (check latest news on the website) which is a high level framework around Direct3D11 (with a XNA like API, but with full Direct3D11 support). SharpDX is the only C# wrapper covering the whole DirectX API that is certified to work under Windows 8.
  • MonoGame which is using SharpDX for its Metro backend. I haven't heard that you need to use MonoDevelop for it, as it is working with an existing XNA project and VS 2012 should work just fine.
  • ANX which is also using SharpDX for its Metro backend.

Concerning the previous answer, If Win8 Modern is assumed, you can't use OpenTK, as OpenGL is not a certified API for the Microsoft App Store and SlimDX is not compatible with Windows 8 Metro.

Related questions

Set resource string to XAML

I know how to set string from resource <TextBlock x:Uid="Text1"/> where Text1.Text is "Hello" But I want to do like this <TextBlock Text = {something here to get GreetingText}/> where GreetingText is "Hello" So …

Read More
How to convert byte array to InMemoryRandomAccessStream or IRandomAccessStream in windows 8

now I've had a problem that is how to convert byte array to InMemoryRandomAccessStream or IRandomAccessStream in windows 8? This is my code, but It did't work, refer the following code internal static async Task<InMemoryRandomAccessStream> ConvertTo(byte[] arr) { …

Read More
BlankPage constructor cannot initialize components

I'm starting learning XAML and I add some code to my BlankPage application. And suddenly a constructor which is initializing a component: public BlankPage() { this.InitializeComponent(); } Stop working. I've got now that error: 'BlankApplication.BlankPage' does not contain a definition …

Read More