Is there a case where delegate syntax is preferred over lambda expression for anonymous methods?

c# .net-3.5 delegates lambda anonymous-methods
dragon picture dragon · Sep 20, 2008 · Viewed 13.2k times · Source

With the advent of new features like lambda expressions (inline code), does it mean we dont have to use delegates or anonymous methods anymore? In almost all the samples I have seen, it is for rewriting using the new syntax.

Any place where we still have to use delegates and lambda expressions won't work?

Answer

James Newton-King picture James Newton-King · Sep 20, 2008

Yes there are places where directly using anonymous delegates and lambda expressions won't work.

If a method takes an untyped Delegate then the compiler doesn't know what to resolve the anonymous delegate/lambda expression to and you will get a compiler error.

public static void Invoke(Delegate d)
{
  d.DynamicInvoke();
}

static void Main(string[] args)
{
  // fails
  Invoke(() => Console.WriteLine("Test"));

  // works
  Invoke(new Action(() => Console.WriteLine("Test")));

  Console.ReadKey();
}

The failing line of code will get the compiler error "Cannot convert lambda expression to type 'System.Delegate' because it is not a delegate type".

Related questions

What is the difference between new Action() and a lambda?

So when I write something like this Action action = new Action(()=>_myMessage = "hello"); Refactor Pro! Highlights this as a redundant delegate creation and allows me to to shorten it to Action action = () => _myMessage="hello"; And this usually works …

Read More
Why can't an anonymous method be assigned to var?

I have the following code: Func<string, bool> comparer = delegate(string value) { return value != "0"; }; However, the following does not compile: var comparer = delegate(string value) { return value != "0"; }; Why can't the compiler figure out it is a Func<…

Read More
How do C# Events work behind the scenes?

I'm using C#, .NET 3.5. I understand how to utilize events, how to declare them in my class, how to hook them from somewhere else, etc. A contrived example: public class MyList { private List<string> m_Strings = new List&…

Read More