Replace important symbolic link ‘safely’

bash symlink
Michał Górny picture Michał Górny · Sep 6, 2009 · Viewed 9.8k times · Source

I would like to change the target of symbolic link from within a bash script. The problem is that the symlink is quite important (it's /bin/sh, namely) and I would to do it in fashion that:

  1. New target will be available immediately after removing old, i.e. there will be no possibility that something will notice disappearing of it,
  2. There will be no possibility that the change will fail in the middle, i.e. leaving user with symlink removed and no new one.

I thought about two methods. Either using plain ln:

ln -fs /bin/bash /bin/sh

or using mv:

ln -s /bin/bash /bin/sh.new
mv /bin/sh.new /bin/sh

Which one will suit my needs better? Is there any possibility that one of them would try to replace the symlink target instead of symlink itself?

Answer

ire_and_curses picture ire_and_curses · Sep 6, 2009

Renaming (mv) is an atomic operation; creating a new symlink is not (delete old symlink; create new one). So you should use mv:

$ ln -s new current_tmp && mv -Tf current_tmp current

Here's a blog post discussing this. Also, if you're worried about what will happen, why not try it on a non-critical symlink first?

Related questions

How do I find all of the symlinks in a directory tree?

I'm trying to find all of the symlinks within a directory tree for my website. I know that I can use find to do this but I can't figure out how to recursively check the directories. I've tried this command: …

Read More
How to check if a symlink exists

I'm trying to check if a symlink exists in bash. Here's what I've tried. mda=/usr/mda if [ ! -L $mda ]; then echo "=> File doesn't exist" fi mda='/usr/mda' if [ ! -L $mda ]; then echo "=> File doesn't exist" …

Read More
How to resolve symbolic links in a shell script

Given an absolute or relative path (in a Unix-like system), I would like to determine the full path of the target after resolving any intermediate symlinks. Bonus points for also resolving ~username notation at the same time. If the target …

Read More