Two foreign keys referencing the same primary key

user1263981 picture user1263981 · Jul 1, 2012 · Viewed 33.3k times · Source

Is this okay to have two foreign keys in one table referencing one primary key of other table?

EmployeeID is a primary key in the employee table and appearing as a foreign key twice in the timesheet table.

There will be few admin users filling up timsheets on the behalf of other employees.

In the timsheet table field 'TimsheetFor' will have employeeID of that person who has worked on projects and field 'EnteredBy' or 'FilledBy' will have employeeid of that person who has filled up this timesheet.

Which of the following option is correct?

NOTE: Tables are showing only those fields which are related to this question.

enter image description here

Answer

Kevin Aenmey picture Kevin Aenmey · Jul 1, 2012

I would go with option 1. It is perfectly fine to have two foreign key columns referencing the same primary key column in a different table since each foreign key value will reference a different record in the related table.

I'm sure option 2 would work, but you would essentially have a 1-to-1 relationship between TIMESHEET_TABLE and TIMESHEET_FILLED_BY, making two tables unnecessary and more difficult to maintain.

In fact, if both ENTERED_BY and TIMESHEET_FOR are required in pairs, using option 1 makes far more sense because this is automatically enforced by the database and foreign keys.