How would you compare Apache Tomcat & Glassfish as production servers?

apache deployment glassfish webserver
Satya picture Satya · Nov 29, 2008 · Viewed 24.5k times · Source

I have a J2EE-based system which is running currently on Apache Tomcat. We are in discussions to move our production servers to the Glassfish server.

Can someone share their experiences with either of them?

Answer

Johannes Schaub - litb picture Johannes Schaub - litb · Nov 29, 2008

They are not really comparable.

Apache Tomcat is not a J2EE Server. It's merely a Servlet Container for Web-Applications. Nothing more. If you need J2EE API implementations, you have to take those from elsewhere. For example by using the Apache Geronimo Server which uses Tomcat as its container, or by taking the JAR files from Glassfish.

Glassfish is a complete Java Application Server with implementation for APIs like JPA, EJBs and more. Glassfish contains a Servlet Engine initially used by Tomcat, but they improved it (don't know what exactly). More recent glassfish servers use another container using grizzly which uses the NIO API for input/output and scales quite well. As far as i know, the Glassfish Servlet Engine is more performant. Here i've found a nice benchmark (it's a bit old though):

http://weblogs.java.net/blog/sdo/archive/2007/05/how_to_test_con.html

Related questions

Deny access to .svn folders on Apache

We have a rails application in subversion that we deploy with Capistrano but have noticed that we can access the files in '/.svn', which presents a security concern. I wanted to know what the best way to do this. …

Read More
Deploying Go web applications with Apache

I can not find a mod_go for deploying Go web applications. Is there any other way to run web applications in Go with an Apache web server (or even IIS)? Update: Now after doing Go full time for nearly …

Read More
Rails 3.1 Deploy to Production (with Apache & Passenger) Asset Problems

Rails 3.1 has changed the way it handles the asset pipeline and it is causing issues when deploying to production. I am using Apache and Passenger, which seem to work fine. My production is setup like this (for now). # congif/environments/…

Read More