Android graphics for XXHDPI

android graphics drawable image-scaling
otinanai picture otinanai · Jun 28, 2013 · Viewed 9k times · Source

I'm about to adjust all drawables for an Android app for XXHDPI devices (like sony xperia Z and samsung s4). After thorough reading on Google's documentation, blogs, and SO, I'm confused as to the graphics I'm about to produce.

My concerns are the following:

  1. Google states that I shouldn't worry about this density as it scales up XHDPI graphics - In the same manner, (before XXHDPI devices) why the production of XHDPI graphics was a necessity and it didn't scale up HDPI graphics?

  2. Sony reminds developers not to exclude XXHDPI screens without clarifying if this concerns making adjustments to graphics - Do I have to redesign all graphic elements for XXHDPI?

  3. Based on (2), Sony Xperia Z Ultra has 342dpi density but it is categorized as an XXHDPI device. - If I produce the graphics for an XXHDPI, which is twice the size of an HDPI density, the graphics will scale down by almost 1/3 to match Sony's density and this is undesirable. Why doesn't Xperia Z use the XHDPI drawables? What if I have a pattern and I can't afford any scaling since I'll lose the detail of the pixel-perfect pattern?

  4. Are XXHDPI resources REALLY necessary?

I hope somebody can answer all the questions above.

EDIT

Below are the results of slightly scaling a graphic to adjust to various densities

XHDPI pattern - xhdpi image (1:1) no scaling

XHDPI scaled up by 10% - xhdpi scaled up by 10%

XHDPI scaled down by 10% - xhdpi scaled down by 10%

The detail loss is obvious at 2nd and 3rd image.

Answer

dmon picture dmon · Jun 28, 2013
  1. Unless you actually need your graphics to be "pixel perfect", scaling up from XHDPI will probably be fine for almost all cases. Pixels are so small the user won't be able to tell the difference. Do you actually have an XXHDPI device you can see your graphics on? You might have to provide XXHDPI resources for some drawables, just like you sometimes have to provide MDPI drawables when the HDPI ones don't scale down well.
  2. "do not exclude" in this context means explicitly from the manifest. Some developers target densities in their manifest and that will affect the app not showing in the Play store, this is unrelated to actual graphics.
  3. From that same page, it actually says that the density of that device is 440 dpi? - "One of the awesome features you’ll find in the recently announced Sony Xperia Z is its 5” screen, which boasts a display density of 440 dpi,"

Related questions

Android: Background Image Size (in Pixel) which Support All Devices

I am creating an Application which will run on all Android Devices. I want to create xhdpi Graphics for My App. My App is full screen. I am confused in Creating graphics. can any one tell me the best sizes …

Read More
Calculating the angle between the line defined by two points

I'm currently developing a simple 2D game for Android. I have a stationary object that's situated in the center of the screen and I'm trying to get that object to rotate and point to the area on the screen that …

Read More
How do I get the height and width of the Android Navigation Bar programmatically?

The black navigation bar on the bottom of the screen is not easily removable in Android. It has been part of Android since 3.0 as a replacement for hardware buttons. Here is a picture: How can I get the size of …

Read More