Web Services -- WCF vs. ASMX ("Standard")

.net wcf web-services visual-studio asmx
jdiaz picture jdiaz · Aug 9, 2008 · Viewed 11.3k times · Source

I am working on a new project. Is there any benefit with going with a WCF web service over a regular old fashion web service?

Visual Studio offers templates for both. What are the differences? Pros and cons?

Answer

Nathan picture Nathan · Aug 10, 2008

What is a "regular old fashioned web service?" An ASMX service, or are you using WSE as well? ASMX services are not naturally interoperable, don't support WS-* specs, and ASMX is a technology that is aging very quickly. WSE (Web Service Enhancements) services DO add support for WS-* and can be made to be interoperable, but WCF is meant to replace WSE, so you should take the time to learn it. I would say that unless your application is a quick an dirty one-off, you will gain immense flexibility and end up with a better design if you choose WCF. WCF does have a learning curve beyond a [WebMethod] attribute, but the learning curve is over-exaggerated in my opinion, and it is exponentially more powerful and future proof than legacy ASMX services.

Unless your time line simply cannot tolerate the learning curve, you would be doing yourself a huge favor learning WCF instead of just sticking with ASP.NET Web Services. Applications will only continue to become more and more distributed and interconnected, and WCF is the future of distributed computing on the Microsoft platform.

Here is a comparison between the two.

Related questions

WCF Service Client: The content type text/html; charset=utf-8 of the response message does not match the content type of the binding

I've got a WCF Service running on my local IIS server. I've added it as a service reference to a C# Website Project and it adds fine and generates the proxy classes automatically. However, when I try and call any …

Read More
Guid is all 0's (zeros)?

I'm testing out some WCF services that send objects with Guids back and forth. In my web app test code, I'm doing the following: var responseObject = proxy.CallService(new RequestObject { Data = "misc. data", Guid = new Guid() }); For some reason, the …

Read More
How to generate WCF service with SvcUtil.exe

I am using SvcUtil.exe to generate IClassName.cs file from wsdl file and that is working fine. My problem is that I do not know how to generate ClassName.svc file using command arguments for SvcUtil.exe. After running …

Read More