Why are there two incompatible session state types in ASP.NET?

.net asp.net asp.net-mvc-3 session-state
Drew Noakes picture Drew Noakes · Mar 27, 2011 · Viewed 12.7k times · Source

I see two means of working with session data in ASP.NET MVC:

  • System.Web.SessionState.HttpSessionState, available on HttpApplication
  • System.Web.HttpSessionStateBase, available on Controller

Data stored in one seems to be available in the other.

Unfortunately the only common ancestor of these two types is System.Object, meaning that I can't create reusable utility code for the abstraction of either.

Why is the API this way? Is there an important difference between the two that I am missing?

Answer

Darin Dimitrov picture Darin Dimitrov · Mar 27, 2011

In ASP.NET MVC abstractions over the classic HttpContext objects Request, Response, Session were introduced. They represent abstract classes and are exposed all over the MVC framework to hide the underlying context and simplify the unit testing because abstract classes can be mocked.

For example for the session object you have HttpSessionStateBase and its implementation HttpSessionStateWrapper.

Here's an example of how to convert between the classic ASP.NET session and the abstraction:

HttpSessionStateBase session = new HttpSessionStateWrapper(HttpContext.Current.Session);

So the System.Web.SessionState.HttpSessionState which you are referring to is the underlying session object which existed ever since classic ASP.NET 1.0. In MVC this object is wrapped into a HttpSessionStateWrapper. But since ASP.NET MVC is an ASP.NET application you still get the Global.asax in which you have the bare session.

Related questions

In C#, what is the difference between public, private, protected, and having no access modifier?

All my college years I have been using public, and would like to know the difference between public, private, and protected? Also what does static do as opposed to having nothing?

Read More
How to Convert JSON object to Custom C# object?

Is there an easy way to populate my C# Object with the JSON object passed via AJAX? This is the JSON Object passed to C# WEBMETHOD from the page using JSON.stringify { "user": { "name": "asdf", "teamname": "b", "email": "c", "players": ["1", "2"] } } …

Read More
Invalid postback or callback argument. Event validation is enabled using '<pages enableEventValidation="true"/>'

I am getting the following error when I post back a page from the client-side. I have JavaScript code that modifies an asp:ListBox on the client side. How do we fix this? Error details below: Server Error in '/…

Read More