.NET assembly loading priorities

.net assemblies gac
Dante picture Dante · Oct 22, 2009 · Viewed 7.2k times · Source

I have a solution with 3 projects (GUI, BL and DAL). The DAL assembly is signed and deployed in the GAC.

When I build the solution the DAL is compiled and the assembly placed in the bin folder of the main project. But when I run the application, it loads the GAC version instead of the local one. Why is this?

I realized that because the version in the GAC was not the latest one and some methods were missing, although it compiled fine.

Does the GAC have priority over the local bin folder?

Tks in advance

Answer

Shay Erlichmen picture Shay Erlichmen · Oct 22, 2009

Short answer Yes, the GAC has precedence over local files.
this is a different behavior from what we are used to in native dll world (excluding some system dlls that where always loaded from SYSTEM32 no matter what).

Why?
Imagine that you have multiple applications with the same assembly now that assembly has a bug how do you fix all of your applications? It hard to start search for all the applications on all drivers, its easier to deploy a single assembly to the GAC ans fix all the application at once.

As for your problem, if you change API you need to change the assembly version of that assembly, this way the fusion engine will pick up the version that is in the local folder.

Related questions

How can I list all registered assemblies in GAC?

How can I list all the assemblies that are in the GAC? Do I need a tool that makes it easy to view them?

Read More
Gacutil.exe successfully adds assembly, but assembly not viewable in explorer. Why?

I'm running GacUtil.exe from within Visual Studio Command Prompt 2010 to register a dll (CatalogPromotion.dll) to the GAC. After running the utility, it says Assembly Successfully added to the cache, and running gacutil /l CatalogPromotionDll shows that the GAC …

Read More
How to prevent a .NET application from loading/referencing an assembly from the GAC?

Can I configure a .NET application in a way (settings in Visual Studio) that it references a "local" assembly (not in GAC) instead of an assembly within the GAC, although both assemblies have the same name and the same version?

Read More